Why You Spend More on Subscriptions Than You Think

Brian Page
10 minutes ago
4 min read

In a recent session with clients, I helped them review their household spending to ensure their financial choices aligned with their priorities.

As we worked through their spending, we noticed several streaming services they hadn't used in months. We found a productivity app that one of them had downloaded during a free trial, and a cloud storage subscription they no longer needed. $15 here and $10 there adds up.

If that experience sounds familiar, you're not alone. Research from C+R Research found that 74% of U.S. adults say it's easy to forget about recurring monthly subscription charges. Even more surprising, consumers' actual monthly subscription spending is, on average, 2.5 times higher than what they estimate.

I'm not perfect either. I thought I had canceled a relatively expensive recurring Adobe subscription, but did not get a confirmation email. Two weeks later, I was charged $140 for a service I no longer needed. I contacted them right away, and they refused to refund me. Fine, I canceled, received the confirmation email this time, and then sold $15,000 in their stock because I don't do business with companies like that. (Quick note: I'm an index fund guy, and this stock was less than 2% of my brokerage account portfolio).

Anyhow, for couples trying to manage money as a team, understanding why subscriptions are so easy to overlook can help prevent hundreds or even thousands of dollars from quietly slipping through the cracks each year.

Why Subscriptions Feel Different Than Other Purchases

Think about the last time you spent $120 on a household item. You probably researched it, discussed it, and carefully considered whether it was worth the cost.

Now think about eight subscriptions that cost $15 per month. The annual cost is the same, but the decision feels completely different. Once the payment is automated, the charge fades into the background. We continue receiving the benefits while becoming less aware of the ongoing cost.

That's because subscriptions separate the enjoyment of a product from the pain of paying for it. Dan Ariely did a lot of research on this topic and produced this excellent video tutorial going into more detail.

Companies use this to their advantage by offering lower-cost subscription fees in increments that don't feel as expensive as they do over longer periods of time.

The Psychology That Keeps Us Subscribed

I need to nerd out for a second with some terms. Behavioral finance offers several explanations for why people continue paying for subscriptions long after they've stopped receiving meaningful value.

Loss Aversion

Research consistently shows that people dislike losses more than they enjoy gains. When you consider canceling a subscription, your brain focuses on what you'll lose rather than what you'll save. You imagine the show you might want to watch next month, the workout app you might use someday, or the premium feature you could need in the future.

The Sunk Cost Fallacy

The sunk cost fallacy occurs when we continue investing in something simply because we've already invested time or money into it. Think about sitting through the first 30 minutes of a bad movie with an hour to go, but you keep watching. We can do this when we gamble and lose but keep coming back.

Status Quo Bias

People generally prefer to leave things as they are, and canceling a subscription requires effort. You need to remember your password, log in to your account, navigate to account settings, and complete the cancellation process. Dark patterns make it harder, and finding the time to do it doesn't help.

How Couples Should Evaluate Subscriptions

Rather than reviewing subscriptions one at a time, evaluate them together as part of your household financial system. When reviewing recurring charges, ask four simple questions:

Did we use this in the last 30 days?

Regular use doesn't automatically justify a subscription, but a lack of use should raise concerns.

Would we subscribe if we didn't already have it?

This question helps eliminate the sunk cost fallacy.

Does it solve a real problem?

Some subscriptions genuinely improve your life. Budgeting tools, family organization apps, and cloud storage services may save time, reduce stress, or improve communication. Others simply remain active because nobody has taken the time to cancel them.

What goal could this money support instead?

This question often gives couples the clarity they need to make better decisions.

The Good News About Modern Consumers

The subscription landscape is changing. Research suggests consumers are more likely to subscribe to services when cancellation is easy, and renewal terms are transparent. Companies that provide clarity, flexibility, and straightforward cancellation processes tend to earn more trust and loyalty over time.

If a company makes pricing hard to understand, hides renewal information, or creates obstacles to cancellation, that's a big red flag, and is why I told Adobe to "kiss my *ss."

Schedule a Quarterly Subscription Audit

One of the simplest habits couples can adopt is a quarterly subscription review. Set aside 20 minutes every three months and review all recurring charges across your bank accounts, credit cards, and app stores. Apps and programs can help you uncover your subscriptions.

Be sure to read the terms and conditions, especially the pricing, to make sure the apps are worth the cost.

Professional Support

For those seeking professional support, I'm the only Certified Financial Therapist™, Accredited Financial Counselor®, and Fair Play Facilitator®, empowering high-achieving couples with systems to manage money and the home as a team — drawn from decades of national leadership and lived experience.

Click here for more details about how and when I can help you.

Follow Modern Husbands

Modern Husbands Podcast

Winning ideas from experts to manage money and the home as a team. 2023 Plutus Award Finalist: Best Couples or Family Content

🔔 Click here to listen and subscribe to the Modern Husbands Podcast on Apple.

🔔 Click here to listen and subscribe to the Modern Husbands Podcast on Spotify.

Modern Husbands Newsletter

Click here to subscribe for winning ideas to manage money and the home as a team.