Cooking at Home vs. Eating Out: The Real Cost for Busy Couples
If you're scrolling through social media and stumble upon personal finance content, chances are you've seen someone who makes you feel guilt or shame for your $6 cup of coffee. Eating out is stupid too, that is, if you're listening to them.
But the algorithms aren't telling you the truth: the best financial decision isn't always the one that costs the least.
The Total Truth About Food
Food decisions involve more than money, particularly for dual-career couples. They also involve time, stress, work schedules, family responsibilities, and the mental load of deciding what's for dinner every night.
Sometimes cooking at home is clearly the smartest choice. Other times, paying for convenience enables you to save time you don't have. I'm not going to tell you in this post that it only makes financial sense to stop eating out. What I'll be laying out is how to weigh your family's priorities against your spending choices.
Home Cooking Usually Costs Less, But
Cooking at home is almost always the best way to spend the least amount of money. But lower cost doesn't automatically mean greater value. A meal that costs less but creates unnecessary stress or results in wasted food isn't always the better financial decision.
Restaurants Sell More Than Food
The value of a restaurant is the time you pay someone else to plan the meal, purchase the food, prepare it, cook it, serve it, and clean up afterward. Depending on where you're eating and who's cooking at home, the meal can taste better.
Some evenings, it makes sense for dual-income couples juggling life's responsibilities to eat out. I know what it feels like for my wife and me to be exhausted after a long day of work. The last thing we want to do is cook and clean up after dinner. Those are the days when it makes the most sense to eat out, only if it's something you've budgeted for.
Takeout Isn't Always a Bargain
Takeout can be expensive. Really expensive. Delivery fees, service charges, menu markups, and tips can quickly push the total close to—or even above—the cost of eating at the restaurant. Finance Buzz researched the average additional cost of using delivery services. The graphic below illustrates their findings.
If you decide to order food, compare the total cost of delivery with picking it up yourself. Eliminating delivery fees and service charges can make takeout a much better value while still providing the convenience you want.
Meal Kits Can Provide Unexpected Value
Meal kits are commonly criticized because they cost more than buying groceries yourself. While that's true on a per-meal basis, grocery prices don't tell the whole story.
I used meal kits for a while when our kids were at home. They eliminated much of the meal planning, simplify grocery shopping, and reduced food waste through pre-portioned ingredients.
The comparison you should be making is meal kits versus what your family would realistically do if the meal kit weren't available.
Convenience Foods Aren't Always a Waste of Money
Personal finance experts often encourage families to prepare everything from scratch. I sometimes felt guilty using them, it felt lazy, even when my family liked what I served.
My go-to's are rotisserie chickens, pre-made salads, and chopped fruit. Click here for 14 quick and easy rotisserie chicken recipes.
Time Has Financial Value Too
The work for every meal is visible and invisible. Someone has to plan the menu, create the grocery list, shop for ingredients, prepare the food, cook the meal, and clean the kitchen afterward. Depending on the meal, that process can easily consume an hour or more.
For some families, cooking together is enjoyable and meaningful. For others, it's one more responsibility at the end of an already exhausting day. Your time has value, and protecting it can sometimes be a worthwhile investment.
Beware of False Savings
The least expensive option isn't always the most economical. Buying groceries that spoil before you use them, purchasing oversized packages that go to waste, or getting takeout because you never planned meals all increase your overall food costs.
Build Restaurant Spending Into Your Budget
Decide together how many times you'll eat out, when takeout makes sense, and which occasions deserve a special meal. Planning restaurant spending in advance removes guilt and keeps your food choices aligned with your broader financial goals.
The Right Choice Depends on Your Family
No single approach works for every household. A family with newborn children, challenging careers, or extensive travel may reasonably favor convenience more than a retired couple with abundant free time. Likewise, some couples genuinely enjoy cooking together, while others consider it another household task that competes with already limited time.
The healthiest financial habit isn't cooking every meal at home or avoiding restaurants altogether. It's making intentional food decisions that reflect your family's budget, values, schedules, and priorities.
Follow Modern Husbands
Modern Husbands Podcast
Winning ideas from experts to manage money and the home as a team. 2023 Plutus Award Finalist: Best Couples or Family Content
🔔 Click here to listen and subscribe to the Modern Husbands Podcast on Apple.
🔔 Click here to listen and subscribe to the Modern Husbands Podcast on Spotify.
Modern Husbands Newsletter
Click here to subscribe for winning ideas to manage money and the home as a team.
