How Not to Argue About Money This Holiday Season

Surveys show that people who plan their holiday spending are less likely to go into debt than those who spend without a plan.
I hear the same story year after year. Credit card debt following the holidays leads to financial stress and plenty of tension in the relationship. But it's usually not one big thing. It's grabbing an unplanned gift here and there or letting go when you travel.
Plenty of research shows that couples who talk constructively about money and build spending plans are less stressed and happier in their relationships.
What the Research Says About Budgeting and Financial Stress
National holiday spending surveys show a clear divide between two groups: those who plan their holiday spending and those who don’t.
Couples Who Have Spending Plans (Budgets)
Folks with a holiday budget are far more likely to spend within their means and avoid credit card debt, a truth that shows up even more clearly in academic research on what’s called mental budgeting. Mental budgeting is the way we categorize and plan spending in advance.
Couples Without Spending Plans (Budgets)
Those who don’t build spending plans often burden themselves with some combination of the following three consequences.
They are more likely to...
overspend,
carry credit card balances into the new year,
report regret about how much they spent.
Why Holiday Budgeting Is Harder for Married Couples
I don't like to budget for the holidays. It stresses me out. The mental and emotional labor of holiday budgeting is heavy. That's why it's essential to share it, or at a minimum, be sensitive and supportive of the partner who does.
Holiday budgeting is especially hard because it brings together a long list of touchy topics and our own money stories. Here is a handful of examples:
Different family traditions
Different gift expectations
Different ideas about experiences versus stuff
Different comfort levels with debt
Different assumptions about “what we always do”
Reduce Holiday Season Money Arguments With Spending Plans
I encourage folks to schedule a Money Date to build out a plan for the holiday spending. When you do, use the following three steps as a road map for your conversation.
1. Start the Conversation on a Positive Note
Start by reminiscing about your favorite gift-giving moments. Give each other 5-10 uninterrupted minutes to share their own, and then take turns. When you're each done, identify what went right, and lead with that in mind.
2. Compartmentalize Holiday Spending
Holiday spending is a planned splurge that you've hopefully planned for over the year or have enough cash set aside to spend without going into debt.
Planning isn't limited to gifts. It includes the travel, cost of hosting, school events — and even decorations. Prioritize what matters most to you.
3. Agree on a Number
Setting one number for the overall holiday season creates the needed clarity to build out a spending plan. Couples can decide to give each other some flexibility as long as it doesn't exceed the agreed upon number.
Related: Money Marriage U Budget is a free practical course designed for couples.
Wrapping It Up
Your spending plan is only some of the work that goes into making the holiday season magical. Be aware of the unpaid labor that's needed. That, in itself, is an important enough topic for another post. So I wrote one!
Read, How to Balance Emotional Labor and Mental Load in a Marriage: Holiday Edition to learn more.
Professional Support
I'm the only Certified Financial Therapist™, Accredited Financial Counselor®, and Fair Play Facilitator®, and I empower high-achieving couples with systems to manage money and the home as a team—drawing on decades of national leadership and lived experience.
Click here to learn more about how and when I can support you.
Modern Husbands Newsletter
Click here to subscribe for winning ideas to manage money and the home as a team.
Modern Husbands Podcast
Winning ideas from experts to manage money and the home as a team. 2023 Plutus Award Finalist: Best Couples or Family Content
🔔 Click here to listen and subscribe to the Modern Husbands Podcast on Apple.
🔔 Click here to listen and subscribe to the Modern Husbands Podcast on Spotify.



