Men, Mental Load, Modern Marriage and Fatherhood
People didn't talk about the mental load years ago. At least people weren't naming it. But of late, the term has ignited a national conversation. I credit women for bringing that conversation to the forefront, and it went viral because it spoke to their pain of not being seen for much of the work they do inside the home.
Take, for instance, these survey results, which found that mothers handle 72.57% of the cognitive labor (mental load). And one of my more popular posts is a deep dive into the mental load: The Ultimate Guide to the Mental Load: What You Need to Know for a Stronger Marriage.
But the mental load is not exclusive to women. Framing it as such, just as framing home labor as "women's work," is counterproductive at best.
According to the report, The Cognitive Labor of Being a ‘Good’ Dad:
"Today’s dads are carrying far more cognitive and emotional work than previous generations, and they’re doing it with a deep desire to be better, more connected fathers. Fathers think constantly about how to show up, how to nurture, how to guide, and how to rewrite the scripts they inherited."
This post is an honest, research-backed conversation about the hidden mental load for modern husbands and dads, and how men can feel better in their role.
The Mental Load Explained
The "mental load" refers to the cognitive and emotional burden of continuously organizing, planning, and managing the daily and long-term tasks. We experience a mental load in everything we do, at work and at home. It's invisible work and can be more stressful than physical tasks.
Balancing the Mental Load
Research conducted by Dr. Jan-Bennet Voltmer and his team found that gender doesn't determine how much mental load we shoulder, but, as you can see below, it does predict where we focus our attention.
If a couple sat down and drew this graph as their ideal in their relationship, it would illustrate fairness. The problem arises when it doesn't, and since most U.S. households include two full-time workers, that can happen in many homes.
Mental Load Examples at Home
Let's consider something as arbitrary as toothpaste. Who notices when it's low? Who compares toothpaste and chooses the best one? Who plans to buy the toothpaste? Who will do all of these things before the toothpaste runs out?
There are countless examples of toothpaste in our home, and we can't expect one person who also works full-time to keep track of them.
Mental Load Examples at Work
Before I started writing this post, I considered which points mattered most so couples could understand what each other was experiencing. I grounded my perspective in research, so I reviewed various studies. Based on what I reviewed, I needed to share the lessons in constructive, plain ways to make it easier to learn from the post and take action.
I'm sure you can come up with your own examples in your career.
The Three Core Mental Loads Men Carry as Fathers
Much of my writing focuses on women's experiences. I work hard to share how, as men, we can better understand those experiences to be better partners. This post is different because it's written to help men validate what they're experiencing and help women better understand us.
The Cognitive Labor of Being a ‘Good’ Dad identifies three types of cognitive labor that define how today’s fathers think about being a good dad: Active engagement, emotional engagement, and generativity.
Active Engagement
Earlier in my life, I worked 80+ hours a week outside of the home. It seemed like the right choice for our family at the time. I don't know; maybe it was. But it left me constantly questioning whether I was doing enough.
And I'm not alone. The report found that fathers think constantly about whether they are physically and practically involved:
Am I spending enough time with my kids?
Am I sharing the domestic load fairly?
Am I planning activities, routines, and solutions or just helping with execution?
Many dads describe feeling guilt when work schedules conflict with availability, especially during high-pressure times like school breaks or busy seasons at work. They don’t just want to be present. They want to be purposefully present.
Maybe that's why so many of us volunteer to coach our kids' sports teams or lead activities. I always did, and looking back, it was one of the best choices I made as a dad.
Emotional Engagement
Today’s dads want to bond. We don't want to be seen as nothing more than a paycheck. Emotionally engaging with our kids is a priority.
One of the points made in the research about the mental and emotional labor we experience as dads really stuck with me.
Men described rehearsing conversations internally, thinking deeply before reacting, and trying to unlearn the “toughen up” messages they received growing up. We consider our tone and work hard to be patient. We want our kids to feel safe coming to us with problems.
Generativity
I was a tiger dad. We sent our kids to the best schools. I planned every activity and their downtime, thinking almost entirely about how it would help them in adulthood. I taught AP Micro and Macroeconomics and followed it closely. I worry about how a continuous rise in inequality would impact my own kids if I don't prepare them to excel in their careers.
Research shows this is the kind of thinking most fathers do. This forward-looking mental load is powerful and, at times, emotionally heavy. I regret not spending enough time simply living in and enjoying the moment.
The Benchmark Men Use: Their Own Fathers
A striking finding from the research is how often dads compare themselves to their own parents. I was blessed. My dad is a hero of mine. He worked two jobs, and he was also a teammate at home. My mom was disabled, so it was up to all of us to pitch in. So, to be frank, I don't relate to these findings, but you might.
Anti-models: “I want to be different.”
Many fathers use their childhood experiences as a motivator not to repeat mistakes, not to be distant, not to be the uninvolved dad they saw.
Good but not good enough: “I’ll keep the good, adjust the rest.”
Others look back with appreciation but still try to evolve, adding more emotional presence, more patience, or more shared responsibility.
Moving Forward
Today’s fathers do far more mental and emotional labor than generations before them, and they do it with heart. I work hard to share ideas to manage money and the home as a team. If what I've shared resonates with you, and you want to work toward being a better husband, take advantage of my free weekly newsletter and podcast.
Modern Husbands Podcast
Winning ideas from experts to manage money and the home as a team. 2023 Plutus Award Finalist: Best Couples or Family Content
🔔 Click here to listen and subscribe to the Modern Husbands Podcast on Apple.
🔔 Click here to listen and subscribe to the Modern Husbands Podcast on Spotify.
Modern Husbands Newsletter
Click here to subscribe for winning ideas to manage money and the home as a team.
